« Artistic assault | Main | Effect of antidepressants exaggerated due to buried data »

January 17, 2008

Can stress stop the menstrual cycle?:

Inkling has an interesting article on the effect of stress on the menstrual cycle that investigates the received wisdom that stress can prevent periods.

It turns out the scientific studies have found no conclusive answer as they've returned mixed results, but this may be because they don't adequately distinguish between physical stress and psychological stress.

A range of physical health problems are known to halt menstruation. Malnutrition is a common example and this is why women with anorexia often don't have periods.

Of course, physical and psychological stress go hand in hand, but one study that looked at healthy young women under a great deal of psychological stress, but no major physical health problems, found no alteration in the menstrual cycle.

So Ellison examined female juniors at Harvard who were preparing for the MCAT [Medical College Admission Test] and compared their anxiety levels (and ovulation schedules) to women who were not preparing for the MCAT. In order to make sure there were no other factors at play, all the women were otherwise physically healthy, were not using any oral contraceptive pill that would change hormone levels, and all reported normal ovulation...

But despite the significant increase in stress, there was no change in ovulation or periods in either group. No matter how stressed these students were about the upcoming exam, they continued to have a visit from Aunt Flow right on schedule. This was even the case during the final days and weeks leading up to the MCAT exam, when the subjects described intense stress levels that only Harvard pre-meds can sustain. The study was published in the December 2007 issue of the American Journal of Physical Anthropology.

There's more on the effects of stress on menstruation in the article.


Link to Inkling article 'Of Stress and Periods'.

Vaughan.

Posted at January 17, 2008 05:00 PM

Comments

syntheticjesso says:

I clicked on this article expecting it to say that stress can stop menstruation, since it happened to me. I was under a lot of stress from different places (work, school, and emotional stress) and my period stopped for about nine months in 2004-2005. I started on the pill in 2006, and in early 2007 I was under a lot of emotional and work stress, and it managed to make me a few days late despite the pill.

Of course, I am the type that does not handle stress well. In early 2007, when I was late, stress also made me nauseas for a month and a half. Extreme stress effects me very severely. It makes me wonder if maybe the women in the study are just better adjusted to extreme stress, so it doesn't effect them physically like it does other people.

Comment posted at January 18, 2008 03:51 AM

rj says:

To syntheticjesso: Maybe your extreme reaction to stress translates into physical effects for you. It sure sounds like it, with a month and a half of queasy stomach! Maybe it caused you to miss out on a balanced diet, slow down exercise, and whatnot. If stress makes you physically ill, then it would put you into the physiological group, which would be right in line with the research.

Comment posted at January 18, 2008 03:14 PM

JussiR says:

Distinguishing between psychological and physical stress seems bit vague. I mean can you have physical stress without the psychological one? And if not, then phycsical stress is just a result of psychological stress that the mind/body could not handle. My ex thought she had become pregnant when we broke up, since her perioids were two weeks late. Ends up it was just stress and apparently has happened to her also before.

Comment posted at January 19, 2008 11:56 AM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?